ISO/IEC JTC1/SC22/WG5 N1663 

      Result of vote on Second Draft Technical Corrigendum 2, N1660

Affirmative votes were received from 

Malcolm Cohen
Aleksandar Donev 
Michael Ingrassia
Bill Long
Toon Moene
Steve Morgan  
David Muxworthy 
Dan Nagle 
Mallory North
John Reid
Van Snyder
Stan Whitlock


Rob James voted as follows:

No, for the following reasons:

In subclause 4.4.4.1, while I do agree that "or <derived-type-spec>" needs
to be in the edit for [41:9+], I believe that the "or <derived-type-spec>"
at [41:33+] is incorrect.  This list is about the meaning of an asterisk
for a <char-length>, which can't appear in a <derived-type-spec>.  If the
text "or <derived-type-spec>" is removed from the edit for [41:33+], I'll
change my vote to a yes.


David Muxworthy, Michael Ingrassia, Richard Maine, John Reid, and 
Van Snyder indicated that they agreed with Rob. 


The vote therefore passes with Rob's change made.