==============================================================

ISO/IEC JTC1/SC22/WG5 N2235

Minutes of (Hybrid) Meeting of ISO/IEC JTC1/SC22/WG5
Hosted by J3, the US Member Body for JTC1/SC22
Held at Lawrence Berkeley National Labs, 
One Cyclotron Rd, Berkeley CA, USA
June 27-28, 2024.

Notes:
1.  This meeting of SC22/WG5 immediately followed INCITS/Fortran
    meeting 233. 
2.  WG5 papers are referenced as Nnnnn. They are available from
    https://wg5-fortran.org/documents.html
3.  INCITS/Fortran meeting papers are referenced as J3/23-nnn.
    They are available from https://j3-fortran.org/
4.  To the extent practicable, members will have the opportunity to 
    participate virtually through Zoom


                  Meeting of ISO/IEC JTC1/SC22/WG5
                          June 27-28, 2024
                     Berkeley CA, and Virtual

              Thursday, June 27 1315 - 1700 (PT, UTC-7)
              Friday, June 28 0830 - 1700 (PT, UTC-7)


1. Opening of the Meeting: 1:15PM, June 27, 2024

List of Participants:

Steve Lionel (USA) WG5 convenor

Austin Bullock (USA)
Reuben Budiardja (USA)
Daniel Chen (Canada)
Tom Clune (USA)
Malcolm Cohen (UK)
Brian Cornille (USA)
Hidetoshi Iwashita (Japan)
Ted Johnson (USA)
Gary Klimowicz (USA)
Mark LeAir (USA)
Bill Long (USA)
Raghu Maddhipatla (USA)
Lorri Menard (USA)
David Muxworthy (UK)
John Reid (UK)
Brad Richardson (USA)
Kate Rasmussen (USA)
Soren Rasmussen (USA)
Damian Rouson (USA)
Aury Shafran (USA)
Jon Steidel (USA)
Masayuki Takata (Japan)

2. Opening business

2.1 Introductory remarks from the Convenor

The convenor welcomed both local (in-person) and remote participants
to the meeting.

2.2 Reminder of the ISO Code of Ethics and Conduct

The convenor reminded participants of the ISO Code of Ethics and Conduct, 
available at        
https://www.iso.org/files/live/sites/isoorg/files/store/en/PUB100011.pdf

2.3 Welcome from the Host

Damian Rouson welcomed local participants to the Lawrence Livermore
National Laboratory.
    
2.4 Local arrangements

Kate Rasmussen explained the arrangement for the meeting.

2.5 Appointments for this meeting

Drafting committee: Tom Clune (Chairman)
    Masayuki Takata, Daniel Chen, John Reid

Librarian: Steve Lionel
Secretary: Lorri Menard

2.6 Adoption of the Agenda N2229

The agenda was adopted.

3. Matters arising from the Minutes of the 2023 meeting (N2226)

Steve Lionel reported that the documentation font issues with the
ISO editors was postponed for the 2023 standard, and will be recognized
for the next standard.  This means the committee was able to publish the
2023 standard in calendar year 2023
  
4. Status of 2023 Resolutions (N2225)

Paragraph numbers in programming language standards
 Latest ruling from ISO allows paragraph numbers.

Availability of Working Group documents
 No change

Requirements for Fortran 202y
 This meeting will be considering more items from Japan, Germany and US

TR on Avoiding Vulnerabilities in Programming Languages
 John Reid reported there has been a vote on the full document,
 but that the Fortran annex has not yet been voted on.
     
5. Reports

5.1 SC22 Matters (Convenor)

Other SC22 committees are also taking issue with recent rulings
from ISO editors.

5.2 National Activity Reports

Japan:   N2217 is output of activity
Canada:  No report
UK:      No report
Germany: B2230 DIN feature request
US:      Continues to hold 3 meetings a year working F202y

Unfortunately we lost Reinhold Bader (representative from Germany)
John Reid to see if there's someone to take his place
        
5.3 Report from Primary Development Body (INCITS/Fortran Chair)

INCITS/Fortran continues to work actively on all aspects of the 
Fortran standard.

5.4 Reports from other Development Bodies (Editors/Heads)

No report this meeting.

5.5 Liaison Reports

Liaison reports were presented under INCITS/Fortran business.

6. WG5 Business and Strategic Plans

6.1 Goals for 2024-2026

Publish standard by EOY2028, final choice of content by 06/24

Recessed 1600 June 27, 2024

==============================================================

Reconvene 0830 June 28, 2024
      
7. Update work item list for the next revision ("202Y")

Proposal to create new category "Conditionally accepted" on the work list
was adopted unanimously.
The list of items in N2234 (from N2220 + additional) was agreed. 

8. Closing Business

8.1 Future meetings

A preliminary offer to host the 2025 in Helsinki has been made by
Jeff Hammond.

8.2 Any other business

There was no other business

9. Adoption of Resolutions

The resolutions in N2233 were all adopted unanimously.

10. Adjournment: 0950, June 28, 2024

==============================================================